"ROE V AWARE WOMAN" DOCKET

ABORTION INDUSTRY IN MELBOURNE, FLORIDA
LAWSUITS
ROE V AWARE WOMAN
"ROE V AWARE WOMAN" DOCKET

U.S. District Court
Middle District of Florida (Orlando)

CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE NO: 99-CV-0850-CIV-ORL-19A (6:99cv850)

Roe v. Aware Woman Center, et al
Filed: 07/09/99
Assigned to: Judge Patricia C. Fawsett
Jury demand: Plaintiff
Demand: $1,000,000
Nature of Suit: 440
Lead Docket: None
Jurisdiction: Federal Question
Dkt# in other court: None
Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act

JANE ROE, II,
Plaintiff,
Christopher F. Sapp
Law Office of Christopher F. Sapp
1323 Wilderness Lane
Titusville, FL 32796-1012
321/268-8758

Michael R. Hirsh
Hirsh & Heuser, P.C.
125 TownPark Dr., Suite 300
Kennesaw, GA 30144
770/420-8224

v.

AWARE WOMAN CENTER
FOR CHOICE, INC., a Florida corporation,
Sheldon D. Stevens
[terminated 01/27/00]
[COR LD NTC]
Andrew William Menyhart
[COR LD NTC]
Stevens & Menyhart, P.A.
160 McLeod St.
P.O. Box 541760
Merritt Island, FL 32954-1760
407/453-2221

EDWARD W. WINDLE, JR.,
Sheldon D. Stevens
[terminated 01/27/00]
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]
Andrew William Menyhart
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]

PATRICIA B. WINDLE, and
Sheldon D. Stevens
[terminated 01/27/00]
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]
Andrew William Menyhart
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]

WILLIAM P. EGHERMAN, M.D.
Richard E. Ramsey
[COR LD NTC]
Wicker, Smith, Tutan, O'Hara,
McCoy, Graham & Ford, P.A.
390 N. Orange Ave., Suite 1000
P.O. Box 2753
Orlando, FL 32802-2753, USA
407/843-3939
Sheldon D. Stevens
[terminated 01/27/00]
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]
Andrew William Menyhart
(See above)
[COR LD NTC]
Defendants.

7/9/99 Doc. 1 COMPLAINT filed with demand for JURY TRIAL under Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act (FACE)

7/9/99 -- MAGISTRATE JUDGE CASE ASSIGNMENT Magistrate assigned: Karla R. Spaulding (jrm)

7/9/99 -- FILING FEE PAID. (Filing Fee $150.00 Receipt #83866) (jrm)

7/9/99 Doc. 2 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE by Jane Roe II with Local Rule 1.04(c) - related to 97-1197-Civ-Orl-19B and 99-416-Civ-Orl-19B (jrm)

7/9/99 -- SUMMONS issued for Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman (jrm)

7/14/99 Doc. 3 NOTICE of designation under Local Rule 3.05 - TRACK 2. (ctc) (jrm)

7/15/99 Doc. 4 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Aware Woman Center 7/12/99 Answer due on 8/2/99 for Aware Woman Center (jrm)

7/15/99 Doc. 5 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Edward W. Windle Jr. 7/12/99. Answer due on 8/2/99 for Edward W. Windle Jr. (jrm)

7/15/99 Doc. 6 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Patricia B. Windle 7/12/99 Answer due on 8/2/99 for Patricia B. Windle (jrm)

7/15/99 Doc. 7 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to William P. Egherman 7/14/99 Answer due on 8/3/99 for William P. Egherman (jrm)

8/3/99 Doc. 8 MOTION by defendant William P. Egherman to dismiss the complaint (jrm) Granted by [29] ORDER

8/3/99 Doc. 9 MEMORANDUM by defendant William P. Egherman in support of [8-1] motion to dismiss the complaint (jrm)

8/11/99 Doc. 10 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of [3-1] track 2 notice by plaintiff Jane Roe II (jrm)

8/16/99 Doc. 11 NOTICE of attorney appearance for defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman by Sheldon D. Stevens, Andrew William Menyhart (jrm)

8/16/99 Doc. 12 MOTION by defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman to dismiss complaint (jrm) Granted by [29] ORDER

8/16/99 Doc. 13 MEMORANDUM by defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman in support of [12-1] motion to dismiss complaint (jrm)

8/16/99 Doc. 14 MOTION by defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle, Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman to strike redundant, immaterial, impertinent and scandalous matters from plaintiff's complaint (jrm) Denied as moot by [29] ORDER

8/16/99 Doc. 15 MEMORANDUM by defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman in support of [14-1] motion to strike redundant, immaterial, impertinent and scandalous matters from plaintiff's complaint (jrm)

8/19/99 Doc. 16 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of [3-1] track 2 notice by plaintiff Jane Roe II (jrm)

8/23/99 Doc. 17 RESPONSE by plaintiff Jane Roe II to [8-1] defendant Egherman's motion to dismiss the complaint (jrm) [Entry date 08/24/99]

9/7/99 Doc. 18 RESPONSE by plaintiff Jane Roe II to [14-1] defendants' motion to strike redundant, immaterial, impertinent and scandalous matters from plaintiff's complaint (jrm)

9/7/99 Doc. 19 RESPONSE by plaintiff Jane Roe II to [12-1] defendants' second motion to dismiss complaint (jrm)

10/1/99 Doc. 20 CASE MANAGEMENT REPORT. (jrm) [Entry date 10/04/99]

10/7/99 Doc. 21 ORDER scheduling preliminary pretrial and scheduling conference for 9:30 10/20/99. Scheduled for Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding 10-06-99) ctc (jrm)

10/20/99 Doc. 22 MINUTE ENTRY: Preliminary Pretrial Conference held on 10-20-99 before Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (jrm)

10/21/99 Doc. 23 SCHEDULING ORDER setting Joining of parties, amending of pleadings on 7/5/00; Deadline for filing of motions 9/1/00; Discovery cutoff 8/1/00; Pretrial statement due on or before 11/17/00; Jury Trial set for 1/2/01. Scheduled for Judge Patricia C. Fawsett (signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding) ctc (jrm)

10/21/99 Doc. 23 SCHEDULING ORDER setting Final Pretrial Conference for 10:00 11/30/00. Scheduled for Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding) ctc (jrm)

11/12/99 Doc. 24 MOTION by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support to proceed anonymously (spr) Denied by [29] ORDER

11/22/99 Doc. 25 MEMORANDUM by defendants Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in opposition to [24-1] plaintiff's motion to proceed anonymously (jrm)

12/1/99 Doc. 26 MEMORANDUM by defendant William P. Egherman in opposition to [24-1] plaintiff's motion to proceed anonymously (jrm)

12/23/99 Doc. 27 MOTION by defendant William P. Egherman with memorandum in support to compel plaintiff to respond to interrogatories and request to produce - referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (jrm) DENIED as moot [34]

12/30/99 Doc. 28 MOTION by William P. Egherman with memorandum in support to compel the plaintiff to respond to interrogatories and request to produce - referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (spr) DENIED as moot [34]

1/4/00 Doc. 29 ORDER granting [8-1] motion to dismiss the complaint; granting [12-1] motion to dismiss complaint; denying as moot [14-1] motion to strike redundant, immaterial, impertinent and scandalous matters from plaintiff's complaint; denying [24-1] motion to proceed anonymously. Plaintiff's Complaint is dismissed without prejudice. The Plaintiff shall have 10 days from the date of this Order to file an Amended Complaint; failure to file will result in dismissal without further notice. (Signed 1/3/00 by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett) ctc (cbh)

1/12/00 Doc. 30 NOTICE OF APPEAL of [29-1] order by Jane Roe II Appeal Information Sheet Sent to Appellant. Fee Status: pd $105.00 Receipt # 85800 Certificate of Readiness due on 1/27/00 (cbh)

1/20/00 Doc. 31 STIPULATION for Sheldon D. Stevens to withdraw as attorney by defendant Aware Woman Center, defendant Edward Windle Jr., defendant Patricia B. Windle. (maa)[Entry date 01/21/00]

1/27/00 Doc. 32 ORDER granting [31-1] stipulation for Sheldon D. Stevens to withdraw as attorney: (Terminated attorney Sheldon D. Stevens for Patricia B. Windle, Edward W. Windle, and Aware Woman Center. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (maa)

2/1/00 -- NOTICE assigning 11th Circuit case number re: [30-1] appeal; USCA NUMBER: 00-10231 DD. (maa)

2/1/00 Doc. 33 Transcript requested [30-1] appeal Appeal Information Sheet filed. (no transcripts needed) (maa) [Entry date 02/02/00]

2/2/00 -- Certificate of readiness with certified copies of indexed District Court docket sheet sent to USCA re: [30-1] appeal. (maa)

2/8/00 Doc. 34 ORDER denying as moot [27-1] motion to compel plaintiff to respond to interrogatories and request to produce and [28-1] motion to compel the plaintiff to respond to and request to produce. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla Spaulding on 2/7/00 ) ctc (maa)

4/3/00 -- RECORD ON APPEAL sent to USCA re: [30-1] appeal Transmittal includes: (ROA consists of: Volume pleadings: 1) USCA# 00-10231-DD (cbh)

4/11/00 -- Receipt from USCA of Transmittal of record on appeal. (cbh) [Entry date 04/12/00]

2/28/00 APPELLANT'S PRINCIPAL BRIEF appeal USCA NUMBER: 00-10231-DD

3/27/00 BRIEF OF APPELLEES, AWARE WOMAN CENTER FOR CHOICE, INC, EDWARD W. WINDLE, JR. AND PATRICIA B. WINDLE appeal USCA NUMBER: 00-10231-DD

3/28/00 ANSWER BRIEF OF WILLIAM P. EGHERMAN, M.D. appeal USCA NUMBER: 00-10231-DD

4/11/00 REPLY BRIEF OF JANE ROE, II appeal USCA NUMBER: 00-10231-DD

6/28/00 Oral argument scheduled 8/31/00, 9:00 a.m. USCA Building, Courtroom 338, Atlanta, GA

11/3/00 Oral argument held in Jacksonville, Florida

11/28/00 Doc. 35 ORDER The final pretrial conference previously scheduled for 11/30/00 is canceled. Counsel shall file a motion requesting a new scheduling order within 20 days after a decision is entered by the USCA on the pending appeal. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh)

2/14/01 Petition for writ of certiorari placed on docket of U.S. Supreme Court as No. 00-1301.

3/19/01 BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO THE PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI OF WILLIAM P. EGHERMAN, M.D.

3/20/01 BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI BY AWARE WOMAN, ET AL.

4/4/01 REPLY TO BRIEFS IN OPPOSITION BY JANE ROE, II

4/16/01 U. S. SUPREME COURT DENIES CERTIORARI BEFORE JUDGEMENT

6/8/01 ELEVENTH CIRCUIT ORDER

11/30/01 PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

02/19/02 SUPREME COURT DENIES PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

11/6/01 Doc. 36 USCA DECISION (certified copy) [30-1] appeal VACATING District Court's dismissal of the complaint without prejudice. The District Court's denial of Roe's motion to proceed anonymously is REVERSED. The case is REMANDED with instructions that the District Court re-enter its order dismissing the complaint without prejudice, allowing amendment within a reasonable period of time. [30-1] appeal MFR Number Mandate date: 11/2/01 USCA EOD: 6/8/01 USCA # 00-10231-DD (Carnes & Hill, Circuit Judges & Alaimo, District Judge) (igc) [Entry date 11/07/01]

11/6/01 -- RECORD on appeal returned from USCA re: [0-0] appeal (ROA consists of: Volume pleadings: 1) USCA# 00-10231-DD (igc) [Entry date 11/07/01]

11/15/01 Doc. 37 ORDER, reset amended complaint deadline at 12/17/01 for Jane Roe II ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

12/3/01 Doc. 38 MOTION by Jane Roe II to modify the Case Management Order (cbh) [Entry date 12/04/01]

12/12/01 Doc. 39 AMENDED COMPLAINT by Jane Roe II amending [1-1] complaint; jury demand. (maa)

12/21/01 Doc. 40 ANSWER and Affirmative defenses by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle to [39-1] amended complaint (lak)

12/26/01 Doc. 41 ANSWER and affirmative defenses by William P. Egherman to [39-1] amended complaint; jury demand (cbh)

1/10/02 Doc. 42 ORDER granting [38-1] motion to modify the Case Management Order. The parties shall meet and file an Amended Case Management Report within 20 days from the date of this Order. ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

1/28/02 Doc. 43 CASE MANAGEMENT REPORT (cbh) [Entry date 01/29/02]

2/11/02 Doc. 44 ORDER on Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure. Certificate of disclosure due within 11 days from the date of this Order. ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

2/14/02 Doc. 45 NOTICE OF HEARING: set pretrial conference for 10:00, 2/28/02 before Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (maa)

2/20/02 Doc. 46 CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle Re: order (cbh) [Entry date 02/21/02]

2/22/02 Doc. 47 NOTICE of attorney appearance for Jane Roe II by Michael R. Hirsh (cbh) [Entry date 02/25/02]

2/22/02 Doc. 48 CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE by Jane Roe II Re: order (cbh) [Entry date 02/25/02]

2/28/02 Doc. 49 ORDER Mr. Michael Hirsh does not appear to be a member of the bar of this Court. If he wishes to proceed as counsel of record, he must certify that he has been admitted or file a motion pro hac vice. (Local Rule 2.02(a)) ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 03/01/02]

2/28/02 Doc. 50 CASE MANAGEMENT AND SCHEDULING ORDER setting Joining of parties,amending of pleadings on 9/30/02 ; Discovery cutoff 3/14/03 ; dispositive motion filing deadline for 4/4/03 Pretrial statement due on or before 7/7/03 ; Pretrial conference for 10:00 7/11/03 scheduled for Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding. Jury trial set for the term beginning 8/1/03 before Judge Patricia Fawsett. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 03/01/02]

2/28/02 -- Set jury trial for 8:30 8/1/03 scheduled for Judge Patricia C. Fawsett (cbh) [Entry date 03/01/02]

3/7/02 Doc. 51 CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE by William P. Egherman Re: order (cbh) [Entry date 03/08/02]

3/11/02 Doc. 52 NOTICE of attorney appearance for Jane Roe II by Christopher F. Sapp, Esq. (cbh)

3/11/02 Doc. 53 MOTION by Jane Roe II for Michael R. Hirsh to appear pro hac vice referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh)

3/11/02 Doc. 54 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of [53-1] motion for Michael R. Hirsh to appear pro hac vice, [52-1] appear/appearance notice by Jane Roe II (cbh)

3/12/02 Doc. 55 ORDER Defendant Egherman shall comply with the Order on Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure (Question No. 5) within 10 days from the date of this Order. ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

3/12/02 Doc. 56 ORDER granting [53-1] motion for Michael R. Hirsh to appear pro hac vice ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 03/13/02]

3/20/02 Doc. 57 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle for protective order and to bifurcate trial. (maa) [Entry date 03/21/02]

3/20/02 Doc. 58 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in support of [57-1] motion for protective order and [57-2] motion to bifurcate trial. (maa) [Entry date 03/21/02]

3/26/02 Doc. 59 RESPONSE by William P. Egherman to [55-1] order. (maa)

4/3/02 Doc. 60 RESPONSE by Jane Roe II in opposition to [57-1] motion for protective order, [57-2] motion to bifurcate trial (cbh) [Entry date 04/04/02]

4/17/02 -- ENDORSED ORDER denying [57-2] motion to bifurcate trial. Motion [57-1] for protective order is referred to the US Magistrate Judge. ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

4/17/02 -- MOTION referred: [57-1] motion for protective order referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh)

4/18/02 Doc. 61 ORDER denying [57-1] motion for protective order ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 04/19/02]

5/1/02 Doc. 62 NOTICE of change of address of counsel by Jane Roe II (cbh)

9/25/02 Doc. 63 NOTICE of change of address of plaintiff's counsel by Jane Roe II (cbh)

11/19/02 Doc. 64 MOTION by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support for leave to amend [50-1] Scheduling order, and for leave to file Second Amended Complaint (cbh)

11/29/02 Doc. 65 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in opposition to [64-1] motion for leave to amend [50-1] Scheduling order, [64-2] motion for leave to file Second Amended Complaint. (maa)

12/6/02 -- ENDORSED ORDER denying [64-1] motion for leave to amend [50-1] Scheduling order, denying [64-2] motion for leave to file Second Amended Complaint (see doc. nos. 50 & 65) ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 12/09/02]

2/11/03 Doc. 66 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle for summary judgment (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 67 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in support of [66-1] motion for summary judgment (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 68 NOTICE of filing deposition of Edward Windle by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 69 DEPOSITION (copy) of Edward Windle, taken 10/22/02, filed by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle re: [66-1] motion for summary judgment Transcript filed separately. (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 70 NOTICE of filing redacted deposition of Jane Roe, II, by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 71 DEPOSITION of Jane Roe, II, taken 8/27/02, by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle re: [66-1] motion for summary judgment Transcript filed separately. (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 72 NOTICE of filing deposition of Patricia Windle by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 73 DEPOSITION (copy) of Patricia Windle, taken 10/22/02, filed by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle re: [66-1] motion for summary judgment Transcript filed separately. (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 74 NOTICE of filing deposition of William P. Egherman, MD by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/11/03 Doc. 75 DEPOSITION of William P. Egherman, MD, taken 8/28/02, filed by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle re: [66-1] motion for summary judgment Transcript filed separately. (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

2/12/03 Doc. 76 MILBURN ORDER, response to motion set to 3/12/03 for [66-1] motion for summary judgment ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 02/13/03]

3/11/03 Doc. 77 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in opposition to [66-1] motion for summary judgment. (maa)

3/12/03 Doc. 78 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle to compel discovery and for sanctions referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding. (maa)

3/14/03 Doc. 79 MOTION by William P. Egherman, Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle with memorandum in support to extend time to conduct expert discovery referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding. (maa)

3/25/03 Doc. 80 ORDER Counsel for defendants shall confer with counsel for plaintiff by 3/28/03 and file a supplement to defendants' motion to compel reporting the outcome of that conference. Counsel for plaintiff shall make themselves available for the conference on 3/27/03 at 10:00 a.m. or at a time and place mutually agreeable to the parties. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 03/26/03]

3/27/03 Doc. 81 SUPPLEMENT by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle to [78-1] motion to compel discovery, [78-2] motion for sanctions (cbh)

3/27/03 Doc. 82 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in opposition to [78-1] motion to compel discovery, [78-2] motion for sanctions (cbh)

3/27/03 Doc. 83 MOTION by Jane Roe II for partial summary judgment (cbh)

3/27/03 Doc. 84 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in support of [83-1] motion for partial summary judgment (cbh)

3/28/03 Doc. 85 MILBURN ORDER. Response to motion set to 4/23/03 for [83-1] motion for partial summary judgment ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

3/28/03 Doc. 86 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in opposition to [79-1] motion to extend time to conduct expert discovery (cbh)

4/1/03 Doc. 87 ORDER denying as moot [78-1] motion to compel discovery, [78-2] motion for sanctions ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh)

4/3/03 Doc. 88 ORDER granting [79-1] motion to extend time to conduct expert discovery. Plaintiff shall have 20 days from the date of this Order in which to depose Dr. Grimes. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh)

4/14/03 Doc. 89 MOTION by William P. Egherman with memorandum in support for final summary judgment (cbh) [Entry date 04/15/03]

4/16/03 Doc. 90 MILBURN ORDER: response to motion set to 5/12/03 for [89-1] motion for final summary judgment ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 04/17/03]

4/21/03 Doc. 91 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in opposition to [83-1] motion for partial summary judgment. (maa)

4/23/03 Doc. 92 MEMORANDUM by William P. Egherman in opposition to [83-1] motion for partial summary judgment. (maa)

4/28/03 Doc. 93 MOTION by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh)

4/28/03 Doc. 94 DECLARATION of Michael R. Hirsh by Jane Roe II re: [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants (cbh)

4/28/03 Doc. 95 MOTION by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support for Motion hearing on [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh)

4/29/03 Doc. 96 NOTICE OF HEARING: Motion hearing set for 10:00 a.m. on 5/2/03 for [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants scheduled for Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh)

4/29/03 Doc. 97 ORDER granting [95-1] motion for Motion hearing on [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 04/30/03]

4/30/03 Doc. 98 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle in opposition to [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants (cbh) [Entry date 05/01/03]

4/30/03 Doc. 99 NOTICE canceling hearing Re: [93] Motion to Strike previously scheduled for 5/2/03 (by deputy clerk) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 05/01/03]

4/30/03 Doc. 100 ORDER denying without prejudice [93-1] motion to strike Dr. David Grimes as a potential witness for defendants ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (cbh) [Entry date 05/01/03]

5/5/03 Doc. 101 NOTICE of resolution of issues by Jane Roe II re: motion to strike. (cbh) [Entry date 05/06/03]

5/9/03 Doc. 102 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in opposition to [89-1] motion for final summary judgment (cbh) [Entry date 05/12/03]

6/20/03 Doc. 103 RENEWED MOTION by Jane Roe II to strike defendant Egherman's expert witness and for costs and fees referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh)

6/20/03 Doc. 104 MEMORANDUM by Jane Roe II in support of [103-1] motion to strike defendant Egherman's expert witness and for costs and fees (cbh)

6/27/03 -- MOTION no longer referred per Chamber's direction: [103-1] motion to strike defendant Egherman's expert witness and for costs and fees (cbh)

7/3/03 Doc. 105 MEMORANDUM by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman in opposition to [103-1] motion to strike defendant Egherman's expert witness and for costs and fees (cbh) [Entry date 07/07/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 106 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman with memorandum in support to bifurcate trial of liability and damages (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 107 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman with memorandum in support in limine to prohibit plaintiff's counsel from commenting or presenting evidence on certain matters (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 108 PRETRIAL STATEMENT. (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 109 PROPOSED jury instructions by Jane Roe II (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 110 PROPOSED verdict form filed by Jane Roe II (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 111 PROPOSED voir dire questions by Jane Roe II (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 112 PROPOSED jury questionnaire by Jane Roe II (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 113 PROPOSED verdict form filed by Jane Roe II (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/7/03 Doc. 114 PROPOSED voir dire questions by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman (cbh) [Entry date 07/08/03]

7/8/03 -- Diskette of Final Pre-trial Statement filed on left side of folder. RETURNED to Plaintiff's Counsel pursuant to Order #117. (cbh) [Entry date 07/09/03] [Edit date 07/10/03]

7/8/03 Doc. 115 MOTION by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support in limine Re: Plaintiff's prior medical history (cbh) [Entry date 07/09/03]

7/8/03 Doc. 116 REQUEST by Jane Roe II with memorandum in support for judicial notice (cbh) [Entry date 07/09/03]

7/9/03 Doc. 117 ORDER striking [113-1] form proposed verdict, [110-1] form proposed verdict, [109-1] instructions jury, [108-1] pretrial statement as these documents do not comply with Local Rule 3.06. The Clerk is directed to return these documents to counsel. The parties shall file a Joint Final Pretrial Statement and material by 7/18/03. The pretrial conference is continued to 7/22/03. ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ctc (cbh) [Entry date 07/10/03]

7/9/03 Doc. 118 AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING: reset pretrial conference for 10:00 a.m. on 7/22/03 scheduled for Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ctc (cbh) [Entry date 07/10/03]

7/10/03 Doc. 119 ORDER granting [89-1] Dr. Egherman's motion for final summary judgment; granting [66-1] Defendants' motion for summary judgment; denying [83-1] Plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment. Other pending motions are denied as moot. ( Signed by Judge Patricia C. Fawsett ) ctc (cbh)

7/10/03 Doc. 120 JUDGMENT for Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman against Jane Roe II. Civil appeals checklist mailed. (by deputy clerk) ctc (cbh)

7/10/03 -- CASE CLOSED. (cbh)

7/11/03 Doc. 121 ORDER canceling Final Pretrial Conference scheduled for 7/22/03 and relieving parties of the obligation of filing a revised joint final pretrial statement ( Signed by Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding ) ctc (gjs)

7/11/03 Doc. 122 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle with memorandum in support in limine re: trial exhibits (cbh) [Entry date 07/14/03]

7/23/03 Doc. 123 MOTION by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle, William P. Egherman with memorandum in support to tax costs referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh) [Entry date 07/24/03]

7/23/03 Doc. 124 MOTION by William P. Egherman with memorandum in support to recover taxable costs referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh) [Entry date 07/24/03]

7/24/03 Doc. 125 AMENDED MOTION amending [124-1] motion to recover taxable costs [amended] by William P. Egherman referred to Magistrate Judge Karla R. Spaulding (cbh) [Entry date 07/25/03]

7/24/03 Doc. 126 AFFIDAVIT of Michael R. D'Lugo by William P. Egherman Re: [125-1] amended motion to recover taxable costs (cbh) [Entry date 07/25/03]

7/25/03 Doc. 127 BILL OF COSTS taxed in the amount of $3,525.75 ctc (cbh)

7/25/03 Doc. 128 ITEMIZATION OF COSTS by Aware Woman Center, Edward W. Windle Jr., Patricia B. Windle (cbh)

7/28/03 Doc. 129 BILL OF COSTS taxed in the amount of $4,006.87 ctc (cbh)